Last Updated: July 15, 2025

How Shopify stores can sell Magic: The Gathering Cards on Whatnot

Magic: The Gathering (MTG) cards are a staple of the trading card world, with a passionate community of collectors and players. If you run a Shopify store with MTG singles, sealed products, or accessories, you can reach a wider audience by selling on Whatnot. This guide shows you how to get started and maximize your sales using Shop2not.

      Why Sell MTG Cards on Whatnot?
      Large, engaged community of TCG buyers
Live auctions drive excitement and higher prices
Easy inventory export with Shop2not

    

How to List MTG Cards on Whatnot from Shopify

Organize your MTG inventory in Shopify, including card name, set, condition, and rarity.
Use Shop2not to export your MTG products to a Whatnot-ready CSV file.
Import the CSV into Whatnot and review your listings for accuracy.
Host live breaks, auctions, or sales to connect with MTG fans!

Tips for Success

Use clear, high-resolution scans or photos of each card (front and back).
Include details like set, rarity, condition (NM, LP, etc.), and any foiling.
Mention if cards are graded or sealed.
Engage with buyers during live streams to build trust and excitement.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Missing or inaccurate card details
Poor quality or missing images
Incorrect category selection on Whatnot
Not updating inventory after sales

Frequently Asked Questions

      
        Can I export MTG cards from Shopify to Whatnot?
        Yes! Shop2not makes it easy to export your MTG inventory from Shopify to Whatnot in just a few clicks.
        What are the fees for selling cards on Whatnot?
        Whatnot charges a commission on each sale. Check Whatnot’s seller policies for the latest fee structure.
        How do I make my MTG listings stand out?
        Use professional scans/photos, detailed descriptions, and highlight rare or valuable cards. Engage with your audience during live sales for best results.
      
    

Ready to Power Up Your MTG Sales?

Join TCG sellers who are already saving hours every week and increasing their Whatnot sales with Shop2not.

Add Shop2not to Chrome